November 16, 2026 08:41

Follow Lima Blog on

The Belgian bill on videoconferencing in judicial proceedings

Rani Van de Gaer, Research Assistant at KU Leuven


Click here to download.


  1. Introduction

On April 18, 2024, the Belgian parliament has adopted a bill on the organisation of hearings via videoconferencing in the context of  judicial proceedings (Bill of April 18, 2024; Bill of April 5, 2024 (final text)). The adoption of this bill marks an important step in catching up with the digital backlog in Belgium – which is known to be one of the worst across Europe (De Mets, 2021; Team Justice, 2021). In Belgium, the use of videoconferencing technology in judicial proceedings is, indeed, rather limited – especially as a means for the parties involved to appear at and participate in (trial) hearings. This is particularly true for criminal cases – even more so after the Constitutional Court has quashed some of the few provisions to that effect (with regards to hearings on pre-trial detention) in 2018 (Constitutional Court, June 21, 2018). Currently, Belgian law only explicitly allows judicial authorities to remotely interrogate witnesses, experts and suspects residing abroad and to remotely hear juveniles via videoconference (Flemish Decree, October 23, 2020; art. 112 CCP; arts. 16 §2 de juncto 19 §1bis Pre-Trial Detention Act). Despite the lack of a legal basis for other uses of videoconferencing, few courts have used the technology in their hearings (mainly in civil proceedings) – albeit with caution and on an ad hoc basis (Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill, December 1, 2023, p. 3).

The use of videoconferencing, however, has gained momentum during the pandemic as a means to allow (not only juvenile) defendants to participate in hearings and so, to ensure continuity in the administration of justice.  It is in the aftermath of the pandemic, which contributed to the common realisation that videoconferencing can make justice more accessible and efficient, that the above-mentioned bill was drafted in order to provide a (hitherto missing) general legal framework on the use of videoconferencing in judicial proceedings (Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill, December 1, 2023, p. 4).. Although the bill also applies to civil proceedings, this blog post is limited to a discussion of criminal proceedings only – which corresponds to the fourth chapter of the bill. The latter chapter is divided into several sections that regulate the use of videoconferencing in the context of respectively criminal cases, pre-trial detention cases, cases on the execution of sentences and cases on execution of holding measures. The first section of the bill prescribes the general framework that will apply to each of the above cases – subject to specific derogations that will be set out in the Pre-Trial Detention Act (PTA), External Legal Position Act (ELPA) and Holding Act (HA) (new arts. 38quater Pre-Trial Detention Act, 98/2 External Legal Position Act and 84/1 Holding Act). This section aims at inserting new articles 556 to 562 (“the use of videoconferencing”), 565 to 566 (“recording of the hearing”) and 557 (“data processing in the context of the use of the videoconferencing system”) into the Code of Criminal Procedure.

  • The videoconferencing system

The first set of articles (new arts. 556 until 557 CCP) make up a new Title VIbis in the Code of Criminal Procedure named “the use of videoconferencing.” Videoconferencing is defined as “any direct audiovisual connection, in real time, for the purpose of ensuring multidirectional and simultaneous communication of image and sound and visual, auditory and verbal interaction between multiple geographically distant persons or groups of persons” (new art. 556 §1, 1° CCP). This will be made possible by a videoconferencing system which is defined as “an informatics system, established by the department designated by the King, that allows (a) videoconferencing in accordance with the conditions and requirements of [Title VIbis]; (b) recording a public hearing […]; and (c) facilitating the regulation of the determination of hearings” (new art. 556 §1, 2° CCP).

The first element presupposes that the videoconferencing system is designed so that persons participating via videoconference have the same rights and obligations as those granted to them in the context of a hearing in which no one appears by videoconference (new art. 558, §1 CCP). More specifically, new article 558 §2 CCP lists the safeguards that the videoconferencing system must comply with. First of all, the persons who participate via videoconference must be able to effectively participate in the court proceedings and follow the debates effectively and integrally. In addition, these persons must be able to express themselves and be seen and heard without technical obstacles. Next, the persons appearing by videoconference must be able to consult effectively and confidentially with their lawyer – in case they wish legal assistance. Finally, it must be ensured that recording, storage and any other form of processing of the videoconference by the court or administrator of the videoconferencing system is not allowed, unless explicitly stated otherwise.

In parallel with the bill going through the legislative process, a videoconferencing system that is supposed to meet the abovementioned safeguards has been developed already (Team Justitie, 2024). The developed videoconference system, which is the result of a cooperation between Microsoft, PwC and Cronos, is based on the use of Microsoft Teams and specific video equipment (FOD Justitie, 2024). The system is tailored for court hearings: amongst others, it can accommodate multiple participants, provide secure and confidential (separate) communication channels, test the quality of the sound, image and internet connection, share documents and it allows the judge to maintain control of the proceedings (mute option, virtual waiting rooms etc.). Furthermore, the system is incorporated in the ‘JustCourt’-application which allows case management and is only accessible after authentication and verification of one’s identity (Just Court (fgov.be). Shortly after the adoption of the bill, on May 23, 2024 to be precise, the videoconferencing system has been introduced in the courts of Mechelen, Marche-en-Famenne and Brussels where it is currently being tested (FOD Justitie, 2024).

  • The initiative to videoconference

Despite the promising videoconferencing system, the new article 556 §2 CCP immediately points out at the beginning of the title that the technological capabilities will not detract from the general rule that hearings will take place in person in the courthouse. Consequently, the videoconferencing technology will be used only when expressly initiated. This bill foresees three ways to do so.

Firstly, the investigating courts, the courts of appeal, the president of a court of assize and the Supreme Court may ex officio invite one or more persons or the prosecution to appear or participate by videoconference. This possibility, however, is not available to the sentencing court and the chamber for the protection of society who respectively hold hearings on the sentence modalities and holding measures (new arts. 98/3 ELPA and 84/2 61 HA). The other courts that could suggest videoconferencing, however, can only do so with respect to the first hearing (for the investigative courts), the introductory hearing, the preliminary hearing, the hearing dedicated solely to the handling of civil interests or for the judgment (new art. 560 §1 CCP). In other words, the courts cannot invite someone to appear via videoconferencing in a hearing on the merits. Exceptionally, the case can nonetheless be heard on the merits if the hearing – for which the court suggested videoconferencing –  were to be continued via videoconference with the agreement of all parties and the prosecution, without, however, being able to take the case under consideration (new art. 560 §1 para. 3 CCP). This limitation to certain types of hearings obviously does not apply in the context of pre-trial detention (new art. 38quinquies PTDA).

Secondly, a person themself may request the court for permission to appear at and participate in the hearing by videoconference (new art. 560 §2 CCP; art. 38quinquies §2 PTDA; 98/3 §1 ELPA and 84/2 §1 HA). Unlike in the first case, there is neither a restriction on which court such request can be made to, nor a restriction on the type of hearing for which said request can be made. When videoconferencing is requested by the person in question themself, videoconferencing can be organised in any type of hearing (including a hearing on the merits) before any court (including the sentencing court and the chamber for the protection of society). Admittedly, it will be up for the court to make the final decision on whether or not to organise videoconferencing by either granting or refusing the request.

In both cases – when the person is invited or requests to participate by videoconference –  the video-link will be established only with the latter’s agreement (new art. 560 §5 CCP). This is different in the third and last case where the investigating courts, courts of appeal, the president of a court of assize, the Court of Cassation, but also the sentencing courts and chambers for the protection of society may ex officio prohibit one or more persons from appearing in person (new arts. 560 §3 CCP, 98/3, §2 ELPA and 84/2 §2 HA). In this last case, videoconferencing will be imposed on the person in question without their consent.

  • The conditions for videoconferencing

Before the court proposes or imposes videoconferencing on its own motion, or grants a person’s request for videoconferencing, the court must consider whether the legal conditions are met. First, the use of videoconferencing must be compatible with the particular circumstances of the case, taking into account the duration, stage and complexity of the proceedings, the number of parties, the possibility of interaction, the nature of the dispute, the assistance of a lawyer, the possibilities of appeal, the technical capacity of the prisons, the residence situation of the person in question and the latter’s physical, psychological and vulnerable condition. Second, the aforementioned safeguards that the videoconferencing system must comply with must be fulfilled (new art. 560 §1, §2 para. 3 and 3§ CCP). When the court imposes videoconferencing, there applies a third condition: the videoconference must, moreover, be the only possibility to participate in the hearings because 1) the epidemic emergency has been declared and measures of administrative police has been taken that prevent the person’s physical appearance at the hearing; or 2) there are objective indications of a serious and concrete risk to public safety that prevents the person concerned from being able to attend or prevents, in case the person concerned is detained, the latter’s transport to the court room to be carried out in safety (new art. 560 §3, 3° CCP).

Furthermore, in all three cases, the courts must ensure the public access to the hearing. This can be done either by the videoconferencing system itself – i.e. by making the video-link publicly available – or by access to the courtroom where the hearing is taking place (new art. 559 CCP). In contrast, when the administration of justice is to be taken place behind closed doors – as is the rule with proceedings regarding pre-trial detention, execution of sentences and execution of holding measures (new arts. 38sexies PTDA, 98/4 ELPA and 84/3 HA) –, another safeguard applies in addition to the first two/three conditions mentioned above. Depending on whether the person is deprived of their liberty, either the authorised representative of the director of the prison, the person themself, their lawyer or possibly a judicial officer must confirm to the court that no one other than themselves and optionally other authorised persons are present at the place where the person is at the time of the appearance by videoconference, or can follow what is being said (new art. 561 §1 CCP).

Once it has been decided that the hearing will be conducted by videoconference, all parties will be notified of this decision. When a ban on physical appearance has been imposed, the person concerned may then appeal the decision to the (first) president of the court that gave notification until twenty-four hours before the hearing (new art. 560 §3 para. 3 CCP). There is no such possibility of appeal, however, in the context of pre-trial detention, execution of sentences and execution of holding measures (new arts. 38quinquies §3 para. 3 PTDA, 98/3 §2 para. 3 ELPA and 44 §2 para. 3 HA). Subject to successful appeal (if possible), the person in question is expected to be appearing at the hearing via videoconference. If the person concerned, however, requested or was invited to appear via videoconference, the latter – if not detained – reserves the right to choose before the beginning of the hearing to appear in person nonetheless (art. 560 §5 para. 3 CCP).  Consequently, it is only when the person concerned appears neither via videoconference, nor in person that they will be tried in absentia. This is, however, different if the court has prohibited a person’s physical appearance (art. 560 §5 CCP). In the latter case the person can only be tried via videoconference (or in absentia).

In any case, however, being tried by videoconference is subject to the proviso that all the abovementioned conditions remain fulfilled during the hearing. If the court, on its own motion or on the mentioning by one of the parties, determines during the hearing that the aforementioned legal conditions are no longer met, it will order either the suspension of the hearing until the conditions are again met, or its postponement to another session which can take place either by videoconference or in person (new art. 560 §8 CCP). If, for reasons of force majeure, the hearing on the continuance of pre-trial detention cannot be continued within the statutory time limits, the court may extend this time limit by five days (new art. 38quinquies §5 last paragraph PTDA).

  • Hybrid or online hearings

The above has shown that one or more persons may appear and participate via videoconference on certain conditions. From this follows that “hybrid” hearings in which some persons appear online and some in the courtroom are possible. Moreover, new article 557 CCP allows not only for one or more persons to appear or participate by videoconference, but also for members of the court to be present by videoconference. The rule, however, is that if one or more parties will participate in the hearing by videoconference, the magistrates and the clerk will be present in the courtroom. By way of derogation from this rule, however, the latter may also take their seats elsewhere by videoconference if – in addition to the known conditions that the use of videoconferencing must be compatible with the particular circumstances of the case and that the videoconferencing system guarantees the necessary safeguards – 1) all parties and the public prosecutor give their consent; and 2) the chief justice or judge give their consent to the magistrate or the clerk, respectively. In the context of pre-trial detention proceedings, the investigating judge may also participate by videoconference when the Council Chamber is seated in prison, provided that the above conditions are met and subject to the consent of the chambers and chief justice (new art. 38octies PTDA).

Besides, if the party appearing by videoconference needs assistance by a sworn interpreter, the latter may take their seat in the court room, in the same place as the party or in any other place the court deems appropriate (new art. 560 §9 para. 1 CCP). The same applies when the person is assisted by a lawyer. The lawyer can then take a seat in the courtroom, in the same place as the person concerned or in any other place deemed appropriate by the court (art. 560 §9 para. 2 CCP). Consequently, the bill allows for all kinds of hybrid constellations, as well as fully digital hearings where everyone participates (separately) by videoconference.

  • Recording of the hearing

In addition to providing a legal framework for the use of videoconferencing, the bill also introduces a second new title in the Code of Criminal Procedure called “recording of the hearing.” Under this title, in the new Article 565 CPP, the making of audio or audiovisual recordings of the hearing, its preservation, distribution or any other form of processing without the prior consent of the court is, first of all, being prohibited and criminalised. More specifically, one risks imprisonment from six months to two years and/or a fine from 200 to 10,000 euros. This prohibition applies not only to the public attending the hearing, but also to the persons appearing or participating via videoconference or to any other person other than the administrator or the court (Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill, December 1, 2023, p. 89). Although the administrator of the videoconferencing system and the court are equally forbidden to record the hearing – as mentioned in the beginning of this blog post –, the law exceptionally allows the latter to do so nonetheless; Under the new article 566 CPP, the court may decide to record public hearings (no hearings behind closed doors) when it is of interest for the creation of historical judicial archives or for educational purposes. A ‘historical dispute’ may, for example, refer to disputes relating to terrorism in so far as they relate to events of particular importance for Belgian national history, while an ‘educational case’ may, for example, refer to disputes that represent an important interest for education with respect to the functioning of the justice system (Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill, December 1, 2023, pp. 90 and 378). The recording is, however, subject to the consent of all persons for the recording of their voice or image (new art. 566 CCP).

  • Data processing in the context of the videoconference system

Lastly, a new title VIsexies called ‘data processing in the context of the videoconference system’ will be introduced into the Code of Criminal Procedure. This title merely exists out of article 567 CCP which delegates the infrastructure, administration and control of the videoconferencing system to the administrative committee of the central register for judgments of the judiciary and of the videoconferencing system of Justice. The committee, as appointed administrator, is designated the following tasks: 1) monitoring the respect of the aims of videoconferencing; 2) monitoring the functioning of the system, including its access policy; 3) monitoring the technical infrastructure of the system; and 4) report on the abovementioned tasks (new art. 567 §2 CCP). The committee will, moreover, process the personal data that is necessary for the using of the videoconferencing system (e.g. name, capacity, national register number etc.).

  • Conclusion

Bearing in mind the digital backlog in Belgian courts, the Belgian bill on the organisation of hearings by videoconferencing in judicial proceedings forms a crucial element in the digitalisation of the country’s judicial system. As discussed in this blog post, the bill provides a comprehensive legal framework for both the use and administration of the developed videoconferencing system for purposes of organising, but also exceptionally recording hearings in criminal courts, investigatory courts, courts of appeal, courts of assize, the Court of Cassation, sentencing courts and the chambers for the protection of society – thereby enhancing the accessibility and efficiency of judicial proceedings. The bill has now been submitted to the King for ratification and promulgation, after which it will enter into force the first day of the third month after its publication in the Belgian official gazette (art. 48 Bill, April 5, 2024).

One Response

  1. Thank you for sharing this insightful article! I found the information really useful and thought-provoking. Your writing style is engaging, and it made the topic much easier to understand. Looking forward to reading more of your posts!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email

Related Posts

Sign up for our Newsletter